Marketing

How to Compare Marketing Agency Proposals: A Founder’s Scorecard for Choosing the Right Partner

Team HusbarNovember 18, 20268 min read
How to Compare Marketing Agency Proposals: A Founder’s Scorecard for Choosing the Right Partner

Short answer

To compare marketing agency proposals fairly, judge them on how well each agency understood your business, how clear its strategy is, what exactly is included, how results will be measured and who will do the work, not just on price or how impressive the slides look. Give every agency the same brief, the same deadline and the same questions, then score each proposal against the same criteria with weights that reflect your priorities. Be wary of guaranteed results, vague deliverables and long lock-in contracts. Speak to references, meet the team who will actually run your account and ask for a 90-day plan. Husbar is an agency too, so we have written this as the honest checklist we would want a founder to use on us. The scorecard below is free to copy.

Key takeaways

  • ✓Give every agency the same brief so proposals are comparable.
  • ✓Score understanding, strategy, scope, measurement and team before price.
  • ✓Guaranteed rankings or results are a red flag.
  • ✓Meet the people who will actually do the work.

What to compare in each proposal

AreaStrong proposalWeak proposal
UnderstandingRestates your goals, customers and constraints accuratelyGeneric introduction about the agency
StrategyClear priorities, why these channels, what comes firstA list of every service they offer
ScopeSpecific deliverables, quantities and timelines"Social media management" with no detail
MeasurementAgreed KPIs tied to sales or leads, reporting rhythmVanity metrics only, or no measurement plan
TeamNamed people, roles and time allocatedSenior people in the pitch, unknown juniors after
TermsClear fees, notice period, ownership of accounts and assetsLong lock-ins, agency owns your ad accounts

How to read between the lines

Did they listen?

The best proposals show the agency understood your situation: your margins, your customers, your sales cycle and what you have already tried. If a proposal could have been sent to any business, the work probably will be generic too.

Are they honest about uncertainty?

No agency can guarantee first place on Google, a fixed number of sales or viral content. Google’s own guidance on hiring an SEO warns against guarantees of ranking. Good agencies talk about tests, learning and what they will do if something does not work.

Is the price comparable?

Proposals often bundle different things. One includes ad creative, another charges extra; one includes ad spend in the fee, another does not. Break each into the same lines, such as strategy, creative, media management, content, reporting and ad spend, before deciding which is cheaper.

Who owns what?

Your ad accounts, analytics, website, domain and creative files should be owned by your business, with the agency given access. If the relationship ends, you need to keep your data and history.

How to run a fair agency selection step by step

  1. Write a one- to two-page brief: business goals, target customers, budget range, what has worked and what has not, timeline.
  2. Shortlist three or four agencies with relevant experience, rather than inviting many.
  3. Send all of them the same brief, deadline and list of questions.
  4. Hold a short call with each to answer questions fairly and equally.
  5. Score each proposal on the scorecard below, with each decision-maker scoring separately first.
  6. Meet the proposed team and speak to at least two references for your top choice.
  7. Negotiate scope, KPIs, reporting and terms, including a review point after 90 days.
  8. Tell unsuccessful agencies promptly and give brief feedback, which protects your reputation in the market.

Want this applied to your brand?

We will find the psychology behind your lost sales and show you what to fix first.

Book a Growth Audit

The treasure: agency proposal scorecard (copy into a spreadsheet)

  • Criteria and suggested weights: understanding of our business 20%, strategy and priorities 20%, relevant experience and proof 15%, scope clarity 10%, measurement and reporting 15%, team and capacity 10%, commercial terms and value 10%.
  • Score each criterion 1 to 5, multiply by its weight and add up for a total out of 5.
  • Understanding questions: "Did they describe our customer correctly?", "Did they mention our constraints?"
  • Strategy questions: "What will they do first, and why?", "What will they not do?"
  • Proof questions: "Do they show similar work, with honest context about results?", "Can we speak to a reference?"
  • Measurement questions: "Which numbers will they report, how often, and how do those link to sales?"
  • Team questions: "Who exactly will work on our account, and for how many hours?"
  • Terms questions: "What is the notice period?", "Do we own our ad accounts and files?", "What is excluded from the fee?"
  • Red flags to note: guaranteed results, no measurement plan, unclear scope, pressure to sign quickly, refusal to share references.
  • Final check: "If this agency did exactly what it proposed, would it move our most important number?"

A worked example

Imagine a founder of a Dubai skincare brand comparing three agency proposals. Agency one had the most beautiful deck and the lowest fee, but its scope was vague and it promised a specific sales figure. Agency two had a higher fee but a detailed 90-day plan, named team members, monthly reporting tied to online sales and a clear notice period. Agency three was strong on creative but had little experience with performance tracking. Using the weighted scorecard, the founder and her operations manager scored separately, then compared. Agency two won clearly once the founder broke each fee into the same lines and saw that agency one charged extra for ad creative. This is an illustrative example of the method.

Want Husbar to do this for you?

If you would like a proposal you can score honestly, book a free Growth Audit or Google Meet consultation with Husbar. We review your marketing, explain what we would do first and why, and give you a clear scope, team and measurement plan. You can also run your site through our free 60-second website audit before any call.

In-house, freelancer or agency?

Before comparing agencies, check that an agency is the right model. A single freelancer can work for one channel; an in-house hire makes sense when work is constant and specialised; an agency gives you a team of skills for one fee. Many growing businesses combine an in-house marketing lead with an agency for specialist work.

Set up the first 90 days for success

Agree a short list of goals, the data the agency needs, access to accounts, a weekly or fortnightly check-in and a 90-day review with clear criteria. The first three months are when most agency relationships are made or broken, and clear expectations protect both sides.

How to give feedback to agencies you did not choose

A short, honest note on why you chose another agency is good practice and keeps the door open for future projects. It also signals that your business is professional to work with, which matters in a connected market like the UAE.

How Husbar helps

Husbar is a psychology-led growth agency. If you are comparing proposals, we are happy to be scored on this checklist: we start with a free audit, show you our thinking, name the team and agree measurable goals before you commit, through our psychology-led advertising service and wider services. Our lead generation and growth team can take this on end to end, or support your team. book a free Growth Audit.

Questions to ask before you start

  • What is the one number this agency must move?
  • Have we given every agency the same brief?
  • Who will actually do the work?
  • Do we own our accounts and assets?
  • What happens at the 90-day review?

Key terms

  • Brief: the document describing your goals and needs for agencies.
  • Scope of work: the exact deliverables included in the fee.
  • KPI: a key performance indicator agreed as a measure of success.
  • Retainer: a monthly fee for ongoing work.
  • Notice period: how long either side must give to end the contract.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Choosing on price or presentation alone.
  • Sending different information to different agencies.
  • Accepting guaranteed results at face value.
  • Not checking who owns ad accounts and files.
  • Signing long lock-ins without a review point.

Why lead generation needs a system, not a campaign

One good month of leads is luck. A steady pipeline comes from a system: a clear offer for one ideal client, two or three channels that reach them, a page that converts, fast follow-up and weekly measurement. Build the system once and every month gets easier.

Related reading: how to choose a marketing agency in Dubai, how to brief a marketing agency, digital marketing agency cost in Dubai and signs your marketing agency is not working.

How do I compare marketing agency proposals?+

Give every agency the same brief, then score each proposal on understanding, strategy, proof, scope, measurement, team and terms, with weights that reflect your priorities.

What should a marketing agency proposal include?+

A summary of your goals, a clear strategy, specific deliverables, timelines, KPIs, reporting, the team, fees and contract terms.

Is it a red flag if an agency guarantees results?+

Usually yes. Agencies can commit to work, processes and targets, but no one can guarantee rankings or sales.

How many agencies should I invite to pitch?+

Three or four is usually enough to compare without wasting everyone’s time.

Should I pay for a pitch?+

For large, creative-heavy pitches, some businesses pay a fee for speculative work. For most SMEs, a proposal and a free audit are enough.

Does Husbar generate leads for B2B and service businesses in the UAE?+

Yes. Husbar runs lead generation for service, B2B and consumer businesses across the UAE and Saudi Arabia, from ads and SEO to landing pages and follow-up automation.

How do I get a lead generation plan from Husbar?+

Book a free growth audit. We look at your offer, channels and funnel and send back a practical plan.

Sources

  1. [IPA: Finding an Agency guide](https://ipa.co.uk/knowledge/documents/finding-an-agency-2019/)
  2. [IPA: The Good Pitch](https://ipa.co.uk/knowledge/the-good-pitch/)
  3. [Google Search Central: do you need an SEO?](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/do-i-need-seo)
  4. [Ehrenberg-Bass Institute for Marketing Science](https://marketingscience.info/)
  5. [Meta Business Help Centre: A/B testing](https://www.facebook.com/business/help/1738164643098669)
TH

Team Husbar

Husbar Editorial

Team Husbar is the strategy, psychology and research team at Husbar, a psychology-led growth agency headquartered in Dubai. Together we have worked with 100+ brands over 10+ years.

Want this applied to your brand?

We will find the psychology behind your lost sales and show you what to fix first.

Book a Growth Audit
Marketing AgencyLeadershipFoundersAgency SelectionUAE